Perilocity

Solving for the Commons

So simple!

BN > BE + C

Aldo Cortesi channels Elinor Ostrom and summarizes what we need to fix Internet security by enticing the providers and users of the Internet to manage it as a commons. But first, some background.

Since at least 1997 ("Is the Internet a Commons?" Matrix News, November 1997) I've been going on about how Garrett Hardin's idea of the tragedy of the commons doesn't have to apply to the Internet, because:

3FN + FTC = Some Less Spam From Some ASNs

A research project I'm assisting at the University of Texas at Austin notes that:

On Tuesday 2 June 2009, the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) took legal steps that shut down the web hosting provider Triple Fiber network (3FN.net).

Looking at Autonomous Systems (ASNs) listed in the spam blocklist CBL,

Rip van Security

Gunnar Peterson asks a question:

...how do you primarily rely on network security as we have done for the Web's life, when the Cloud abstracts the network away?

Gunnar points out IT security has been using firewalls and SSL as primary security for every network acccess software change since 1995.

In 1999 when SOAP emerged as a firewall-friendly protocol designed for the explicit reason to go through the firewall, that should have been a wake up call to Information Security that the "firewall + SSL" security architecture was past its prime, but here 10 years later we are still hitting the snooze button.

Here many years after we lost email for everybody but aging geeks and banks, IT security continues to snooze like Rip van Winkle. While the world changes around it:

VZ Port 587: Good Try

Back in February, Verizon announced it would start requiring outbound mail go through port 587 instead of port 25 during the next few months. It seemed like a good idea to squelch spam. Most other major ISPs did it. People applauded Verizon for doing it.

Unfortunately, it seems that if it had any effect it was short-lived. Looking at anti-spam blocklists on a daily basis, a couple of Verizon Autonomous Systems (ASes), AS-19262 and AS-701, do show dips in blocklist listings on the blocklist PSBL in March. But they don't last.

Spammers are very adaptable, partly because the botnets they use are adaptable. Good try, Verizon.

This information is from an NSF-funded academic research project at the University of Texas at Austin business school. Thanks to PSBL for the blocklist data.

-jsq

Tomato monoculture

You Say Tomato, I Say Agricultural Disaster,, By DAN BARBER, New York Times, Published: August 8, 2009:

For years, this kind of breeding has fallen by the wayside — the result of a food movement wary of science and an industrialized food chain that eschews differentiation in favor of uniformity. (Why develop and sell 20 different tomato varieties for 20 different microclimates when you can simply sell one?)

Does it seem that agricultural monocultures are almost always produced by economic greed?

-jsq

"A cyber czar is fighting a network with an org chart."

Good point.

Design in Security; Don't Wait to Defend

Gunnar recommends building in security instead of waiting to catch the horses after they're out of the barn:

The way out of this is for security to get involved in building better systems, getting involved in the system development, Identity management, and coding. Come to the table with useful tools such as Threat Models and Misuse Cases, and make sure you are there early enough to have an impact. Three places to focus are application development, databases, and identity. Time for security to live in code and config not in Visio drawings.

As Gandhi supposedly said about western civilization: "That would be a good idea!"

Iranian Internet Disturbances

Here's an example of some Internet routing in Iran, in this case on the way to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs on Monday 15 June 2009. Normally, routing and latency don't change much. Starting Saturday 13 June, the day after the election, routing and latency have become increasingly disturbed. More here.

Twitter Reschedules

Twitter recognizes that a network upgrade is important, but the role twitter is playing in Iran is more important, and reschedules for 1:30 AM Iranian time. Now that's risk management!

Would that U.S. states had all rescheduled Diebold and the like to the junk heap after the 2000 U.S. election.

Also notice who twitter's hosting service is: NTT America. I've been predicting for years that the U.S. duopoly's intransigence would lead to NTT and other competent international ISPs eating their lunch, and I see it's beginning to happen.

-jsq

Windows Considered Not Ready for the Desktop

R. McDougall takes the high ground for open software:

0. Premise: free and open software will stay indefinitely. Full stop. You may argue eternally, but free software is the ultimate disruptive technology, moving up from the low ground, replacing complicated and ill-fitting proprietary alternatives at every turn, such as web-browsers, e-mail clients, video players, office software, etc., which at one point cost money, but now most people find that they can no longer justify spending money to buy an upgrade for more "Clippy the Happy Assistant". Proprietary software will only be able to stay relevant by searching out ever more niche applications, or by massive expenditure on research in high-end applications for which it will take time for the ideas and algorithms to filter down to the greater community, and thus a brief window of profitability will remain. Software patents are nothing but a destructive force to retard innovation, and with more and more of the technology and legal communities realizing this basic fact, software patents are about to go away forever.

I think he's being a bit optimistic about software patents, but no more so than Windows advocates claiming that open software is a flash in the pan. Then he gets into the undeniable stuff, chief of which is:

1.1 History's greatest playground for malicious software. With unpatched machines on the internet taking only minutes to become infested with viruses, or become a slave bot for massive illegal spamming operations, Windows is a blight on the Internet's infrastructure.

And it keeps getting better. He says he wrote it just as a game, but it pretty much spells out why I don't use Windows, plus why Windows is a menace to the Internet.